Chargeback vs Dispute Letter: Which Should You Choose?
When should you send a dispute letter vs initiating a credit card chargeback? Pros, cons, and the right strategy for each situation.
The Key Difference
A dispute letter goes directly to the company — it's a formal request citing legal grounds. A chargeback goes through your bank — it's a reversal of the charge. Both are powerful tools, but they work differently.
When to Use a Dispute Letter
Use a dispute letter first when: 1) The charge is recent (within 30 days), 2) You have a clear legal basis (FTC rules, GDPR), 3) The company has a history of resolving complaints, 4) You want to preserve the relationship.
When to Use a Chargeback
Escalate to a chargeback when: 1) The company ignores your dispute letter, 2) The charge was unauthorized, 3) The company refuses cancellation, 4) You're within the 60-day FCBA window, 5) The amount warrants the effort.
The Combined Strategy
Best practice: Send a dispute letter first (giving them 14 days to respond), then initiate a chargeback if they refuse. The dispute letter creates a paper trail that strengthens your chargeback case.
Section 75 (UK)
UK consumers have an additional tool: Section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act. For purchases between £100-£30,000 on a credit card, your card provider is jointly liable. This is even stronger than a standard chargeback.
What Dispute Gremlin Provides
Our free templates cover both dispute letters and chargeback support letters. The AI Gremlin generates letters with the exact legal citations for your situation and region.
Need help with a dispute?
Free templates for 173+ services with legal citations.